After the success of Return to Collinwood, a sequel was written by Jamison Selby and performed at the 2005 Dark Shadows Festival. Unfortunately, it was decided not to record the play to audio like its predecessor.
Taking place some time after the events of Return to Collinwood, former Collins family lawyer Tony Peterson arrives in town. It soon becomes clear that Peterson is in fact a descendent of the Reverend Trask. He becomes possessed by Trask's spirit and he is hell-bent on revenge.